Conservative Judaism faces a paradoxical crisis: institutional stagnation has emerged despite decades of organizational growth and successful Jewish integration into American society. A roundtable discussion of six prominent rabbis revealed that the movement's drift toward centrism has diminished the productive ideological tensions that once drove innovation. Through structured dialogue focused on identifying critical issues rather than proposing solutions, participants examined fundamental challenges threatening Conservative Judaism's vitality. The analysis exposed two crucial areas requiring reform: organizational structure and ideological framework. Current synagogue-centered models prove inadequate for addressing declining small communities, increased population mobility, and youth disengagement during college years. Similarly, uncertainty surrounds core theological principles like "Conserving Jewish Tradition" and "Catholic Israel," highlighting the need for clearer doctrinal positioning relevant to contemporary life. The movement requires fundamental redefinition of both methods and ideas, including development of new leadership structures, enhanced national coordination, and ideological clarity that responds to both evolving American society and the reality of modern Israel.