Can an all-powerful God who allows profound suffering still merit humanity's devotion? Rabbi Artson challenges conventional Jewish theology's portrait of a commanding, static deity, proposing instead a dynamic divine presence that guides through gentle persuasion rather than absolute decree. Through theological analysis and comparative study of traditional versus process frameworks, this examination reveals how Artson's "divine lure" model offers a compelling alternative to traditional theodicy. Rather than wielding coercive power, this reimagined deity attracts humanity toward greater order and creativity while preserving human agency. Yet critical questions emerge about distinguishing authentic divine persuasion from potentially deceptive influences. The analysis reveals that while Process Theology provides valuable insights for reconciling divine omnipotence with human suffering—including the Holocaust—fundamental tensions remain between inherited Jewish law and contemporary theological freedom. These unresolved questions demand continued dialogue about moral discernment and divine-human relationships within modern Jewish thought.