The priesthood's role in Conservative Judaism exists in an unresolved state of tension between ancient tradition and modern egalitarian values. Through analysis of Conservative Movement literature, Law Committee proceedings since 1929, and contemporary congregational practices, a striking pattern emerges: the Movement has never systematically addressed priestly status in its curriculum or foundational documents. This gap has led to widely varying congregational approaches to Torah honors (aliyot), priestly blessings (Duchening), and redemption ceremonies (Pidyon Haben). The Federation of Jewish Men's Clubs Pidyon Haben kit has sparked renewed interest in priestly roles, yet field research reveals practices ranging from strictly traditional male-only participation to fully egalitarian inclusion of women (bat Kohanim). As congregations develop independent policies without systematic guidance, a "priestly renaissance" has emerged, marked by inconsistent application of halakhic principles. The findings demonstrate an urgent need for the Conservative Movement to establish comprehensive guidelines and educational frameworks for the priesthood, addressing both theological foundations and practical implementation. A systematic Law Committee review and development of a contemporary "midrash" could transform hereditary priestly status into meaningful synagogue involvement while maintaining halakhic integrity within egalitarian contexts.