A critical shortage of qualified mohalim (ritual circumcisers) in American Jewish communities has created an urgent need to establish formal training programs for Conservative Jewish physician-mohalim. The traditional system of informal apprenticeships that historically produced qualified practitioners has eroded, while malpractice insurance concerns and declining numbers of traditionally trained mohalim further compound the problem. Through analysis of Talmudic, medieval, and modern sources, including religious texts, responsa literature, and contemporary practices across Orthodox, Conservative, and Reform movements, historical precedent emerges for physician-mohalim dating to Talmudic times—challenging contemporary Orthodox objections. While Orthodox communities increasingly restrict cooperation with Conservative institutions, and Reform programs train physicians under different halakhic standards, Conservative Judaism requires its own distinct training approach. The research demonstrates how Conservative communities can address their unique needs through a comprehensive curriculum that combines traditional Jewish learning with medical expertise, maintaining both religious authenticity and appropriate halakhic standards. This evidence-based framework provides a path forward for training Conservative physician-mohalim while preserving essential religious and medical requirements.